History

The History of Mascara

How darkening the lashes moved from soot and elderberry juice to the wand-and-tube format, and why Hollywood made it essential.

A portrait of a woman

A Victorian lady who wanted darker lashes had few options. One popular recipe involved soot mixed with elderberry juice, applied carefully with a fine brush. It was messy, it smudged, and it came off at the first tear. The word mascara itself arrived in English in the nineteenth century, borrowed through French from an Italian word meaning mask. For a long time the product was a mask in the literal sense: a dark paste that you put on and hoped would stay put.

The object that sits in a makeup bag today, a slim tube with a brush on the end, is a twentieth-century invention. Its history runs through Chicago drugstores, Hollywood studios and the chemistry of wax.

Before the tube

Darkening the eye area is ancient. Egyptians used kohl, a soot-based preparation, around the eyes, and Romans had their own versions. Those preparations were closer to eyeliner than to mascara, since the point was to outline the eye rather than to coat individual lashes. Coating the lashes themselves appears to be a more recent idea.

By the late 1800s, European and American women were using homemade mixtures to darken lashes and brows. The recipes were domestic rather than industrial: soot, burnt cork, elderberry juice, sometimes a little oil to help it stick. In the 1910s, a Chicago businessman named Tom Lyle Williams noticed his sister Maybel using something on her lashes. He set out to make a better version, and in 1915 launched a product called Lash-Brow-Ine. The name of the company followed in 1917: Maybelline, a combination of his sister’s name and the gelatine he used in the formula.

The early product was a cake. You wet a small brush, rubbed it over the dark block, and painted it onto the lashes. It worked, after a fashion, and it was sold by mail order at a price that ordinary women could afford. Cake mascara held the market for decades. Some versions survive today, mostly among older users and theatrical makeup artists who like the control it gives.

Hollywood changes the brief

Silent film changed what lashes needed to do. On a black-and-white screen, a pale face surrounded by nothing could look flat and unfinished. Dark, thick lashes framed the eye and read clearly from the back of a theatre. Studios needed a product that would photograph well and survive the heat of the lights.

Max Factor, who had built a cosmetics business supplying actors in Hollywood, developed mascara formulas for the screen in the 1920s and 1930s. The attention to film mattered for the wider market. What the studios put on a star’s face in 1930 was what women tried to copy at home in 1931.

The modern wand arrived in the middle of the century. The idea of a rod with a brush, stored inside a tube with the product, solved the oldest problem in mascara: how to keep the applicator clean and the formula from drying out. It also made the product faster to use. By the 1950s and 1960s, tube mascara was common, and the cake belonged to an earlier era.

What is in the tube

Mascara is a suspension of pigment in a base that hardens as the solvent evaporates. Carbon black provides the deepest black; iron oxides supply browns and softer blacks. Waxes give the film body and help it hold a curl. Oils keep the mixture workable and stop it from flaking once dry.

The main split is between waterproof and washable formulas. Washable mascara uses water as the main solvent, which is why a shower and some soap will remove it. Waterproof mascara replaces much of that water with volatile solvents and adds waxes that resist water. It survives rain, sweat and tears, and it is harder to take off, which is the trade-off. Removing it properly usually means an oil-based cleanser or a dedicated remover, held against the lashes for a few seconds before wiping.

The brush matters as much as the formula. A thick, dense brush deposits more product and gives volume. A slim, comb-like brush separates the lashes and builds length. Curved brushes follow the shape of the eye and lift the outer lashes. In the 2000s, manufacturers began competing on brush design as actively as on ingredients, with rubber brushes, silicone bristles and hourglass shapes each promising a different result.

The 1970s brought waterproof mascara to a mass market, and the 1990s brought the idea of a lash-primer: a white or clear coat applied first to give the colour something to grip. Tubing mascara appeared later, using polymers that form tiny tubes around each lash instead of a continuous film. It comes off with warm water and gentle pressure, which made it popular with people whose eyes reacted to ordinary formulas.

Sensitive eyes and honest claims

Mascara causes more complaints than most cosmetics because it sits next to the eye. Waterproof formulas need stronger removers, and rubbing at a stubborn lash line can irritate the skin and break the lashes themselves. Ophthalmologist-tested is a useful label if you wear contact lenses, though it is not a guarantee. If a product stings, the sensible response is to stop using it rather than to assume that all mascaras do the same.

The marketing around length and volume has always run ahead of the chemistry. A mascara can make lashes look longer by coating them to their tips or by holding a curl, but it cannot make them grow. Products that claim to condition the lashes often contain proteins or panthenol, which can make the coating feel less brittle. Whether that counts as care is a matter of definition.

Choosing one

For daily wear, a washable formula in a shade softer than black is easy to remove and hard to overdo. Black gives the most definition, brown is gentler on fair colouring, and the coloured mascaras that come and go in fashion work best as a deliberate choice rather than a mistake. If you cry often, wear contact lenses or live somewhere humid, waterproof has a practical case, provided you also own a remover and use it.

Applying it and taking it off

The quality of a mascara application depends less on the formula than on how the brush meets the lashes. The standard method is to start at the root and wiggle the brush slowly as it moves upward. The wiggle loads product onto the lashes and separates them at the same time, while a slow upward stroke carries the pigment to the tips. A second coat adds volume but also increases the chance of clumping, so most artists recommend applying one coat, letting it dry briefly, and then deciding whether a second is needed.

The lower lashes require a lighter touch. They are shorter and finer, and a heavy coat tends to transfer onto the skin underneath. Holding the brush vertically and using only the tip gives more control. Any smudge that appears can be removed with a clean cotton bud once the mascara has dried; trying to wipe it while it is still wet usually makes a larger mess.

Curling the lashes before applying mascara changes the appearance of the eye more than most people expect. A curl lifts the lashes away from the lid, making them look longer and opening up the eye. It works best on dry, clean lashes, before any product has been applied, and it should be done gently to avoid breakage.

Removal deserves more attention than it gets. Mascara is worn for eight or more hours on fine hairs that are easy to damage. Rubbing with a dry tissue or a rough cleanser pulls at the lashes and irritates the eyelid. The sensible approach is to hold a soaked cotton pad against the closed eye for a few seconds, let the product dissolve, and then wipe downward. Oil-based cleansers, micellar water and dedicated eye makeup removers all work, and waterproof mascara needs one of the oil-based options.

Some people react to mascara with redness, itching or swelling around the eyes. The cause may be a fragrance, a preservative or the remover rather than the mascara itself. Stopping the product usually settles it, and patch testing a new formula on the jaw for a day or two can prevent a reaction on the eye area.

Mascara has come a long way from soot and elderberry juice. The tube did not change what the product was for; it changed how reliably it could do it. Everything after that, from the curved brush to the tubing formula, has been a variation on getting a dark coat onto a very small surface and keeping it there for a day.