Science

The Science of Acne

What actually causes spots, which treatments have evidence, and why the advice you were given as a teenager was often wrong.

A portrait of a young woman

Acne is the most common skin condition in the world, and one of the most misunderstood. It affects people of all ages, though it is most common in adolescence. It is not caused by dirt, and it is not a sign that a person has failed to wash properly. The advice that generations of teenagers received about scrubbing harder was wrong, and it often made the problem worse.

The good news is that acne is one of the better-understood skin conditions. Its causes are known, and there are treatments with real evidence behind them. The challenge is that these treatments take time and that the most effective ones can irritate the skin.

What causes acne

Acne develops when four things happen together. The first is increased production of sebum, the oil that the sebaceous glands produce. The second is a buildup of dead skin cells in the pore lining, which blocks the opening. The third is the presence of bacteria that normally live on the skin, which multiply in the blocked pore. The fourth is inflammation, the immune system’s response to the bacteria and the trapped material.

A spot begins when a pore becomes blocked with a mixture of oil and dead cells. If the plug is exposed to air, it oxidises and turns black, forming a blackhead. If it is not, it remains a whitehead. When bacteria multiply in the blockage and the body responds with inflammation, the result is a red, tender papule or, if the inflammation is deeper, a painful nodule or cyst.

All four factors are necessary, and this is why a single treatment rarely works for everyone. A treatment that reduces oil will help one person, while another needs something that reduces inflammation or clears the blockage.

The types of spots

Dermatologists distinguish several kinds of acne lesions. Comedones are the non-inflamed blockages, either open or closed. Papules are small red bumps, and pustules are similar bumps with a visible head of pus. Nodules are larger, painful lumps beneath the surface, and cysts are deeper still. Nodulocystic acne is the most severe form and is most likely to leave scars.

The distinction matters because mild acne and severe acne are treated differently. A person with a few blackheads may respond to an over-the-counter exfoliant, while someone with painful nodules usually needs prescription treatment.

Acne also appears in different patterns. It commonly affects the face, chest and back, where the sebaceous glands are most numerous. A person who only has spots in one area may be reacting to something local, such as a hair product or friction from clothing.

Myths that persist

The belief that acne is caused by dirty skin is the most durable myth. Scrubbing does not prevent acne and often makes it worse by damaging the barrier and increasing inflammation. The skin of a person with acne is not dirtier than that of someone without it.

Diet is another area full of claims. Chocolate and greasy food are often blamed, but the evidence is weak for most foods. There is growing evidence that high-glycaemic diets and, in some people, dairy may contribute to acne, but the effect varies and is modest compared with treatments. A person does not need to eliminate whole food groups to clear their skin.

The idea that acne is only a teenage problem is also wrong. Adult acne is common, particularly in women, and may be driven by hormones, stress or cosmetic products. Treating it as a childish complaint leads people to delay getting effective help.

Treatments with evidence

Benzoyl peroxide is one of the oldest and most effective over-the-counter treatments. It kills the bacteria involved in acne and has the advantage of not leading to resistance, since it works by releasing oxygen rather than by a specific biological target. It can bleach fabric and cause dryness, which is why starting with a lower concentration is sensible.

Topical retinoids, including adapalene and tretinoin, help by increasing cell turnover and keeping pores clear. They also have an anti-inflammatory effect. They are among the most effective treatments for comedonal acne, and adapalene is now available over the counter in many countries.

Salicylic acid helps clear pores as a gentle exfoliant, though it is less effective than retinoids for many people. Azelaic acid is useful for both acne and the pigmentation that can follow it.

For more severe acne, a doctor may prescribe topical antibiotics, oral antibiotics or, in the most severe cases, isotretinoin. Oral antibiotics are usually combined with benzoyl peroxide to reduce the risk of resistance. Isotretinoin is a powerful drug with significant side effects and requires careful medical supervision, but it can clear severe acne that has not responded to other treatments.

Building a routine

A routine for acne should be simple. A gentle cleanser used twice a day, a treatment applied consistently and a moisturiser to reduce irritation form the basis. Sunscreen is important in the morning, since many acne treatments increase sensitivity to light.

The most common mistake is to use too many products at once. A person who starts a cleanser, a toner, a serum, a spot treatment and a new moisturiser in the same week will not know which one is helping and which is causing irritation. Introducing one product at a time, and giving it several weeks, is slower but far more effective.

Treatment takes patience. Most products need six to eight weeks to show their full effect, and a temporary worsening in the first weeks is common with retinoids. A person who gives up after a fortnight will never see the benefit.

Diet and lifestyle

The connection between diet and acne is real but limited. A person who notices that a particular food consistently triggers spots can reasonably reduce it, but there is no universal acne diet. High-glycaemic foods and dairy have the strongest evidence, and the effect is greater in some people than others.

Stress does not cause acne directly, but it can make it worse through hormones and through behaviours such as poor sleep and touching the face. Sleep and exercise help general health and may indirectly help the skin.

Skincare habits matter more than most lifestyle factors. Using products that suit the skin, avoiding harsh scrubbing and not picking at spots can change the course of acne more than a change in diet.

Scars and marks

After a spot heals, it may leave a mark. Red or brown marks are areas of inflammation or pigment that usually fade with time and sunlight protection. True scars involve a change in the structure of the skin and are more permanent.

Picking at spots increases the chance of scarring, which is one of the strongest practical pieces of advice. A person who cannot resist picking may find that treating the acne effectively is the best way to stop.

Treatments for marks include niacinamide and azelaic acid for pigmentation, and retinoids for mild textural changes. True scars often need procedures such as laser treatment, which should be discussed with a dermatologist.

Acne in adults

Adult acne is different from the teenage form in a few useful ways. It tends to appear along the jawline, the chin and the lower cheeks, and it is often deeper and more tender than the blackheads and whiteheads of adolescence. Hormonal changes are a common cause, and many women notice a pattern that follows the menstrual cycle.

The treatment principles are similar, but adults often need a longer approach. The skin is slower to recover from irritation, so active ingredients have to be introduced carefully. A routine that is too aggressive can produce a cycle of irritation and breakouts that is hard to break.

Some adult acne is triggered by cosmetics or by hair products, particularly oils that transfer to the skin. Looking at the products used on the face and hair is a sensible early step, and stopping a new product for a few weeks can be informative.

When to see a doctor

A person should seek medical help when acne is painful, when it is leaving scars, or when over-the-counter treatments have not worked after several months. Severe acne with nodules or cysts almost always needs prescription treatment, and early intervention reduces the risk of scarring.

The bottom line

Acne is a condition with clear causes and effective treatments. It is not a hygiene failure, and scrubbing it will not help. A simple routine with one or two evidence-based ingredients, used consistently for long enough, clears most mild cases. Severe cases deserve medical care rather than more products from a shelf.

Acne and self-image

The medical side of acne is straightforward compared with its effect on how people feel. Spots are visible, and they are easy to read as a judgement on the person who has them. This is why the myths about dirt and diet are so persistent: they offer an explanation that places the blame on behaviour.

A person with persistent acne is often better served by effective treatment than by trying to live with it, and early treatment reduces the chance of scarring. It is also worth remembering that the condition is common and that it does not reflect anything about a person’s habits or character.